The advocates of Pro-life and Pro-choice have their own justifications. Pro-choice advocates hold that it is their right to have control over their own body.
The Ethical Dilemma On Abortion
Pro-life advocates hold that from the very conception life start in the womb of a woman. It is actually a Person inside the womb.
So, the question remains, Pro-life or pro-choice? The fight between pro-life and pro-choice is an everlasting battle and the ethical dilemma.
Essay Example: Moral and Ethical Dilemmas of Abortion
First take a look at abortion from a Teleological point of view, it depends solely on consequences. This approach to morality and ethics hold that there is no universal basis for determining what is right. Main idea behind it is the principle of Utility. The principle focuses on the consequence of action, intentions are irrelevant, therefore breaking promise, lying, causing pain or killing someone may under certain circumstances be the right action and in other circumstances, wrong action.
Applying this theory into the topic of abortion, question arises: Do I really need a child? Am I ready for a baby? Do I really want to give up all of my time to raise a baby? This theory seems to focus on a very selfish viewpoint of the situation. Utalitarian theory does not mean that a woman is selfish on her decision of abortion. The woman decides that it would be in her best interest to have abortion at this point. This woman can remain in school and not have to worry about bringing unplanned child, but just because this decision worked out well for her, was it the right decision?
Although this might seemed like a good decision, it still brings concerns and ethical dilemmas to our attention. Could she not have had child , found employment and stayed in school as most people do? Could she not have ultimately ended up being the happiest she has ever been because of this child coming into her life?
This question brings the case in the light of Deontological Theory. This theory has two approaches: Divine command Thoery and System of duties. Thomas Aquinas was the proponent of Divine command theory. According to him the world is created by God. Whatever happens, happens with the will of God. Life is given and taken by him only. A woman who followed the Divine Command theory might have done things differently in the same situation. She might not have based her decision on self interest, nor on consequences, but rather on something higher like God. God has given her this child to birth and care for.
This also face criticism like how can we base a life altering decision on the belief that there is a higher power, God? However, when Christians face an ethical dilemma, they should first consult the Bible and pray that God will show them the option that most closely aligns with what He says in His Word. Also, God is with them,…. Ethical Dilemma Thousands of women have chosen the option to have an abortion, some because of medical reasons, some financial and some have even been forced into the decision from friends, families, and spouses.
However, what exactly makes one except the fact that abortion is neither right nor wrong. I will examine the abortion ethical dilemma per the Christian worldview and look at how another world view perceives the decision….
- science coursework gcse structure!
- i need help with a math problem!
- Critical analysis and evaluation of argument.
There are various types of abortion such as spontaneous abortion, which happens on its own and can also be called miscarriage. Induced abortion that can also be called deliberate termination of pregnancy by surgery or administration of medication. Having an abortion can be a strong decision to make and can affect you for the rest of your life.
Abortions play a large role in the ethical world and affects the worldviews of many people and countries. Ethical Dilemma In this dilemma….
Introduction Abortion is one of many controversial issues. It is a topic that is widely debated among many people. Abortion is a difficult topic of discussion, when the baby is a product or rape, or has Down syndrome or deformities. According to my Christian worldview, I will examine the abortion ethical dilemma, and compare it to other options of resolving the dilemma.blacksmithsurgical.com/t3-assets/poetry/the-lone-rider-v1.php
Abortion: An ethical dilemma.
Ethical Dilemma: The topic on abortion involves my response to a woman who has been struggling between aborting and keeping…. Benchmark Assignment: Ethical Dilemmas The issue of abortion has almost no equal in possessing the potential to polarize two sides of an issue, often resulting in high-emotion and on rare occasions leading to violent reactions including the bombing of abortion clinics and attacks on the doctors who perform them.
The controversial issue was decided in the Supreme Court decision Roe v. However, the issue still remains unresolved in the…. Introduction Elective abortion is considered one of the most influential, controversial, and legally active areas in the field of medicine. Thirteen, against the constitution, ban late-stage abortions, except those performed to save the life or physical health of the woman. Finally there are four states, also against the constitution, that will allow late-stage abortion only to save the life of the woman and does not consider her long term health as an acceptable reason for abortion Guttmacher Institute, In some states the requirement of a second physician is required for some instances of survival of the fetus and treatment and to certify that the abortion was medically necessary in all or some circumstances Guttmacher Institute, Pro-choice doesn't mean what most think it means; pro-abortion, rather pro-choice occupies the middle ground of neither pro-abortion nor forced motherhood.
The pro-choice movement supports and works towards the prevention of unwanted pregnancies, reduction of abortions, promotion of contraception, educating women and youth, and ensuring families have the resources necessary to raise happy, healthy children Arthur, Pro-choice advocates feel that it is a woman's personal right to decide what is best for them given their personal situation. Typically under this advocates opinion late-stage abortion should not be a state issue to weigh in on. With the Supreme Courts ruling during Roe v.
Wade, a milestone was set with regard to woman's freedom and equality, and that a woman's health should always be protected NARAL, para. Late-stage abortion is very rare; according to the Guttmacher Institute only 1. An even smaller margin at 25 weeks 1, Due to the statistical nature of this study and that only 1.
Many women are excited about pregnancy and look forward to their new found roles as mothers; however, for some of these women childbirth can mean enduring great risk to themselves and to their unborn babies due to many adverse health risks.
Why choose our homework help?
I had mentioned above that there are still four states in the U. Some examples of these health risks are as follows:. One in 3, pregnant women also have breast cancer during their pregnancy. Health exceptions considerations should also be made for mental-health problems that may occur in pregnancy andsevere fetal anomalies.
These disorders could cause a tremendous amount of emotional stress on a pregnant woman and her family NARAL, para. Ethical Dilemma of Pro-Choice. There are two things to consider when asking yourself the implications of ethical values in late-stage abortions. One of course is the rights of the mother. Would taking away her right to abortion at any stage disagree with her autonomy? Equal rights also come to mind; how can we force a woman to become a mother but we cannot force a man to become a father?
I truly believe that most late-stage abortions happen for reason other than the ones mentioned above, which with the violation of autonomy, beneficence and non-maleficence, that alone should make late stage abortion the decision of the woman's; however, the second consideration is the health of the woman and the ethical considerations for the unborn fetus should the act of childbirth cause that child a miserable existence due to abnormalities or complications that would cause the fetus to not live after birth.
Non-Considerations for late-stage abortion would absolutely be outside of both the woman's right and the rights of the fetus.
- essay on why higher education is important.
- Introduction to the abortion debate?
- uchicago essay responses.
- Do My Homework for Me | Pay for Expert on tuckpitlaetehy.gq.
- scarlet letter scaffold scene essay.
- Abortion Ethical Dilemma Essay.
By allowing health risk of any kind to the woman would be in violation of beneficence, non-maleficence and justice. Allowing a fetus to be born with major and un-survivable issues is cruel,outside of human compassion and also is in violation of beneficence, non-maleficence and justice. Even though I have made a decent argument that not allowing a woman the right to choose what is best for her body and life is against her autonomy for sure and a bit of ambiguity to the values of beneficence and non-maleficence; I also have to consider the fetus should it be healthy andviable. Stated in our text, Health Care Ethics, chapter 5; fundamentalist Jerry Farwell insisted that unborn babies were the last disenfranchised minority- vote-less, voiceless, and unprotected in the most basic of civil liberties.
Is there truth to this? If not allowing a healthy viable baby the right to be born be considered a violation of that humans autonomy? By choosinglate-stage abortion for mere convenience even though the fetus is viable and healthy considered a violation of beneficence and non-maleficence as this choice in no way benefits the fetus and could be considered doing harm to a viable human. These theorieswill be weighed and my personal determination of the topic will be addressed in the conclusion of this paper. Continuing on the debate, the pro-life position is that a new human life is created the moment of fertilization and is entitled to the same legal and ethical protection as any other human being.
Pro-life advocates look very closely to the link between what is considered a human life and scientific evidence. The pro-lifers make a very clear distinction that a new human zygote has a genetic composition that is absolutely unique from itself, different from any other human, including that of it's mother Schwarzwalder, They feel that it is quite clear that the earliest human embryo is biologically alive and fulfills the criteria needed to establish biological life; metabolism, growth, reaction to stimuli and reproduction Schwarzwalder, Feminist for Life, another pro-life advocate, agrees with the Family research Council and feels that abortion is a reflection that society has failed to meet the needs of women.
Moral and Ethical Dilemmas of Abortion Essay
When it comes to the basic principles outlined under pro-choice, to consider late-stage abortions for ANY reason would constitute in the abandonment of their ethics and principles. The considerations that pro-life constituents take is that there is no moral ambiguity. By not allowing a human life to be born because of anomalies would be the same thing is allowing someone to murder a5 year old for having been handicap Crutcher, Pro-choice and pro-life advocates both have a common ground when it comes to the question about what is constitutional in terms of violating a persons constitutional rights would also be in violation ofa persons ethical values.
The fifth amendment to the U. Constitution says that no person shall be deprived of his or her life without due process of the law. If the establishment was made on whether or not a human fetus could be considered a human life it would evaporate abortion at any stage for any reason Crutcher, People are very divided on whether legislation should be involved on a woman's right to start a family.
Pro-choice defenders feel as if the state took away her right to her own choice that they would be denying her justice and autonomy and in some cases causing her harm.